Security Improvements, Access Code & Mail Communication Preview

LEAD OUT OF TURN

Hi

A trick was won LHO. Before he could lead to the next trick RHO played AH and LHO quickly played the 6H.

Declarer did not play a card and TD was called. Declarer requested the lead to come from correct hand RHO. the AH is clearly a major penalty. Declarer now has option of applying laws 52D2 a) or b). If he selects a) the AH is picked up. What happens to 6H it is also a penalty major card but what law applies to it. Can it also be picked up or is it treated differently ????

Your help would be appreciated.

Started by COLIN BRAY on 31 Oct 2019 at 04:16PM

Post a Comment

You need to be logged in to reply to threads.
Click here to log in.

Latest Posts on this Thread

  1. SHARON MOSLEY31 Oct 2019 at 05:45PM

    Hi Colin

    Interesting question. As I read the above, Declarer has asked for the lead to come from LHO, therefore, as you say, the AH is a major penalty card for RHO.

    As LHO also has a major penalty card Law 50 D applies. This is from World Bridge - 

    "Law 50D – Disposition of More than One Penalty Card In cases where both defenders have a penalty card, lead restrictions caused by partner take precedence over the obligation to play one’s own penalty card. Example 43: LHO on lead has the ♠J as a penalty card, while his partner has the ♠7 as a major penalty card. Declarer now prohibits a spade lead. This means that the ♠7 is put back into the hand, LHO cannot lead his penalty card and in the case where he retains the lead, he still cannot lead the ♠J Effective: January 2019 Updated: January 2019 Page 28 to the following trick(s). If declarer requires a spade lead, the ♠7 goes back into the hand and LHO has to play the ♠J. Although it sounds odd, it might be to declarer’s advantage to choose this option, so we still offer it. If declarer doesn’t exercise his options relating to the ♠7 being a penalty card, LHO must lead the ♠J, and RHO has to play the ♠7. The ramifications of each defender having a penalty card are not obvious even to experienced players, so it is incumbent upon the Director to explain them clearly."

    It also seems to me that the fact partner holds the AH is now unauthorised information, and a lead of the 6H later in play may be suspect.

    Cheers

    Sharon

You need to be logged in to reply to threads.
Click here to log in.
Our Sponsors
  • Tauranga City Council
  • TECT.jpg