All News

Good Advice.   

It was the start of a Butler Pairs event at the local club…the usual pre-match chatter with at one table some discussion as to what Butler Pairs meant. “Is it one of those forms where you have to bid all your games” a less experienced player asked?

“Sure is” said the expert. “It is nice to make overtricks but bidding and making all your games is a very good idea, much more important. “

A few minutes’ later, play was under way…and our expert picked up on the first board the following:

 AQ53

 983

 KJT82

 8

A nice 10 count and first to speak, vulnerable against non-vulnerable opponents. Time to get in early. The hand almost conforms to the “Rule of 20”… 10 high card points,9 cards in the two longest suits, a decent looking diamond suit, a singleton and potential in the “boss” spade suit…. “1”.

The bidding proceeded briskly:

 

So, how’s your nice looking 10 count looking now? Your partner figures to be short in hearts though 3 was bid with a feeling that they may not quite have their bid. Should you take that into account? It really all depends whether partner’s side suit honour cards were in clubs or diamonds. Go on. Be brave. Bid the vulnerable game!

“Pass”! That ended the auction. Wimp!

You laid down your dummy as North led the A. Partner played low and South went into an anguished huddle…finally producing K. Declarer followed low. Trick 2 was mildly surprising! J from North, low hearts from dummy and South with your partner, yes, your partner(!) producing Q! (This board is not one played at any World Championship…just everyday life!)

Are you feeling really wimpish now?! Well you would be when declarer produced a spade to your queen, winning, and A felling North’s king. The remaining trump was drawn and partner produced next… AQ!

 

That was only two overtricks!

Now, I want to stop the flood of emails which will tell me that there were any one of a million ways to beat 4 even after the A lead though I am a little doubtful that a defender who played K at trick 1 (“I guessed you held the Q, partner”) would have found the necessary underlead of AQ required to beat the contract had the K been withheld until trick 2.

4 is as they say a terrible contract requiring a pretty favourable lie of the trump suit, never mind some less than splendid defence. Try making 4 on a club lead and K switch!

Fine words… but in practice, the game made….if only the expert had taken his own advice!

  let's just substitute "play" for "stay"

Richard Solomon

It would be lovely to make this a weekly feature but to do so, it requires some input from you, the readers. Week in, week out, amusing things happen at the bridge table.

 You experience them, observe them. Share them with me and then we all can enjoy. Either email on Richard.Solomon@nzbridge.co.nz  or phone me and tell me about them on 09 232 8494.

No names need be shown but exposing can be part of the fun!

Thanks.  

Go Back View All News Items